Miller-Courtney Letter Calls for Action on Mine Safety Legislation, Recognizes Fourth Anniversary of Upper Big Branch Disaster
WASHINGTON— The House Republican majority still has not considered legislation to improve mine safety and close glaring loopholes in our nation’s mine safety laws that could help save miners’ lives, even as we mark the fourth anniversary of the deadliest U.S. coal mine tragedy in the last 40 years.
Rep. George Miller (D-Calif.), senior Democrat on the House Education and the Workforce Committee, today sent a letter to committee Chairman John Kline (R-Minn.) requesting that the committee mark up and move to the House floor a long-overdue bill that would make significant improvements in mine safety, the Robert C. Byrd Mine Safety Protection Act (H.R. 1373).
On April 5, 2010, an explosion ripped through the Upper Big Branch Mine in Montcoal, West Virginia, killing 29 miners in the deadliest U.S. coal mine disaster in nearly 40 years. Numerous investigations concluded that the reckless conduct by the mine operator, Massey Energy, caused the disaster.
In the wake of this catastrophe, Rep. Miller, then the chairman of the Education and Labor Committee, called the only congressional hearings that included both families and miners involved in the disaster. Since that hearing, four investigation reports have been issued, with MSHA, the state of West Virginia, the West Virginia governor’s independent investigation panel, and the United Mine Workers all concluding that Massey’s violations of widely recognized safety standards caused the explosion.
In response, Miller has introduced and updated the Robert C. Byrd Mine Safety Protection Act in each of the subsequent sessions of Congress, but it has been blocked by Republican opposition.
“The blood spilled by the Upper Big Branch miners will be in vain if Congress does not close the glaring loopholes that allow reckless mine operators to put profit ahead of safety,” said Miller. “There are long overdue reforms to the nations’ mine safety laws that miners, mine safety regulators, and the UBB families have asked Congress to address—reforms that would better ensure that all miners are able to return home safely to their families at the end of their shift. At this point, any further delays in meaningful legislation that would provide miners with modern health and safety protections and honor our promises to the families of the 29 miners who perished four years ago are simply inexcusable. We must mark up the Robert C. Byrd Mine Safety Protection Act immediately and bring it to the House floor.”
Read the full letter below:
April 4, 2014
The Honorable John Kline
Chairman
Committee on Education and the Workforce
U.S. House of Representatives
2181 Rayburn House Office Building
Washington, DC 20515
Dear Chairman Kline:
We write today requesting that you convene the members of our Committee to mark up and move to the House floor long-overdue legislation, the Robert C. Byrd Mine Safety Protection Act (H.R. 1373), a bill that will save miners’ lives and close glaring loopholes in our nation’s mine safety laws that enable mine operators to place profits ahead of safety.
April 5th marks the 4th anniversary of the Upper Big Branch mine disaster where 29 miners were killed in the deadliest U.S. coal mine disaster in the past 40 years. In the past, you have urged that Congress hold off on consideration of mine safety legislation until the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) and others completed their investigations of the UBB tragedy.
Those investigations have been completed for at least two years. It is past time for action.
All totaled, six reports have been issued, including four accident investigation reports and two separate reviews—one internal and the second external—of the agency’s performance vis-à-vis the Upper Big Branch (UBB) tragedy. These reports provided safety agencies, the mining industry and Congress with a roadmap to help prevent future tragedies.
We appreciate your convening the hearing “Lessons Learned from the Upper Big Branch Tragedy” that was held two years ago on March 27, 2012. For several years now, it has been well-known what happened and what went wrong. Democrats have put forward legislation to prevent future Upper Big Branch disasters, Mr. Chairman, and we are puzzled why, with the facts in hand, you have not acted.
We agree with your statement that the genesis of this disaster “lies in Massey’s corporate culture that valued profit over safety.” You have properly noted that “when workers are needlessly put in harm’s way, federal enforcement must require corrective action and hold mine operators accountable.”
Effective federal enforcement depends on both adequate laws and vigilant oversight of conditions in the mines. The March 27, 2012 hearing underscored gaps on both fronts. While MSHA has stepped up to close the gaps in its performance, the Congress has not closed the gaps in the law.
Assistant Secretary Joe Main noted that the tragedy at UBB “shook the very foundation of mine safety” and caused MSHA “to take a deeper look at the weaknesses in the safety net expected to protect the nation's miners.” MSHA’s Internal Review identified 100 action items, and work on 95 of these actions items was completed by December 31, 2013. The 5 remaining areas that require further work—such as entering into Memoranda of Agreements with states or securing resources to implement succession plans—will depend on actions by states or Congress. Nonetheless, MSHA is pressing forward to 100% completion. At your request, the Department of Labor’s Inspector General oversaw MSHA’s efforts, and found that MSHA “implemented an aggressive implementation schedule for the recommendations in its Internal Review report, and has so far met its targets.”
But it is clear that administrative reforms alone cannot compensate for inherent weaknesses in the Mine Act.
Families of UBB miners have asked us to act on legislation to deter the kinds of egregious misconduct that led to this tragedy. MSHA has asked us to provide it with additional, critically important tools to help it overcome well-documented shortcomings in the law.
Testimony provided to the Education and Workforce Committee, coupled with the findings and recommendations in the investigation reports, supports the need to adopt measures to:
- Deter and prevent mine operators from providing advanced notice of inspections to hide violations and hazards from enforcement personnel;
- Increase the consequences for operators who intimidate miners as a way to discourage them from stopping unsafe work or reporting hazards to MSHA;
- Provide MSHA with subpoena authority necessary to uncover malfeasance, such as keeping two sets of books as a way to conceal hazardous conditions from MSHA; and
- Provide a meaningful deterrent for mine operators who show a criminal disregard for the lives of miners.
The Robert C. Byrd Mine Safety Protection Act, which was updated and reintroduced on March 21, 2013, closes these four gaps in the Mine Act, and gives prosecutors the tools they needed to help deter misconduct by the small percentage of mine operators who value profit over safety. The Mine Act provides that willfully violating mine safety standards which results in the death of 29 miners is a mere misdemeanor. The failure to address a weakness this flagrant is an embarrassment.
Four years after this tragedy, and two years after all of the investigation reports have been finalized, inaction by this Congress on needed legislation is both glaring and inexcusable. There is only one message being sent to the UBB families: Congress is closing their ears to their pleas. It is harsh conclusion, but the lack of action leaves the unmistakable impression that Congress as an institution is indifferent to the blood shed by these miners.
Since the March 2012 hearing, this Committee has not held a single hearing on mine safety. Issues that concern miners’ safety and health have fallen off the radar screen during this Congress.
There is still time in this Congress to bring a bill to a markup and the floor of the House for a vote. We are ready and willing to enter into discussions to find common ground. Mr. Chairman, I hope you will decide that the loss of these 29 miners’ lives was not in vain.
Sincerely,
| GEORGE MILLER | JOE COURTNEY |
| Senior Democratic Member | Ranking Member |
| Subcommittee on Workforce Protection |
Next Article