by Ranking Member Bobby Scott and Ranking Member Patty Murray
All around the country, child care workers get up every morning and go to their jobs where they care for, inspire and help raise our youngest learners. They teach our kids how to read, how to hold a pencil, how to take turns and share with their classmates, how to resolve disagreements and so much more.
And yet, at the end of a long, tiring, often thankless day, so many of these professionals go home only to worry about how they will make ends meet.
They are not alone. For too long, education has been put on the back burner: As budgets are slashed in states across the country, too many schools are crumbling, too many students are using old and worn supplies, and too many teachers are not getting paid what they should be for the work they do.
It’s encouraging to see teachers across the country organizing and using their voices to stand together with their unions and demand the tools, and the pay, they need to help our students succeed — and it’s up to all of us, at every level of government, to show that we have their backs. That’s true in K-12 education, which is getting a lot of attention right now, but early childhood educators and child care workers are still being left behind too.
The average child care worker makes a little over $10 an hour, or about $22,290 a year. While the majority of these professionals are low-income women of color with a high school diploma, some have a two-year or even four-year degree — but still many are forced to supplement their salaries with public assistance. When these child care workers are unable to make ends meet, many leave for better-paying jobs in K-12 schools or elsewhere. As a result, our youngest learners and their parents pay the price.
We know the benefits of high-quality early learning and care. The right start in education can lead to a wide range of short- and long-term benefits. Children who have access to high-quality early learning and care are more likely to perform better in school and make more money later in life, and are less likely to commit crimes. Nations across the globe see the same evidence and invest in early childhood education. In the United States, however, too many families struggle to find high-quality care — and those that do often cannot afford the skyrocketing costs. Investing in our youngest learners and the teachers who care for them is not only the right thing to do, it is a smart investment for our economy and our future.
That is why, last year, we introduced the Child Care for Working Families Act. Our bill ensures that no family has to pay more than they can afford on child care. It also prepares our youngest learners for success in kindergarten and beyond by expanding access to high-quality preschool for low- and middle-income 3- and 4-year-olds. Finally, to ensure that we are attracting and keeping the very best, our bill would provide child care professionals and preschool teachers with better training and a livable wage.
This bill has broad support in Congress and from parents, teachers and child care workers around the country. We have 30 co-sponsors in the Senate, over 120 co-sponsors in the House and over 40,000 petitions of support from working families.
Just last month, we passed a bipartisan government funding bill with the largest increase ever for child care and a significant increase for Head Start. This is a strong step in the right direction, but our work is not done.
We will keep fighting until the Child Care for Working Families Act is law, and high-quality child care and early learning for all is a reality.
Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.) is a former preschool teacher and the ranking member of the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions. Rep. Bobby Scott (D-Va.) is the ranking member of the House Committee on Education and the Workforce.
2.Rolled back rules that ensure taxpayer dollars do not go to bad actors. On March 27, 2017, Trump signed a law invalidating rules thatrequired federal contractors disclose their history of labor law violations. The invalidated rules also required agencies to evaluate whether potential contractors stole workers’ pay and endangered worker safety. Moreover, it prohibited contractors from forcing employees to sign away their rights to a day in court if sexual harassment or assault allegations arise.
3. Made saving for retirement even harder. Last spring, Trump signed two laws invalidating rules that allowed states and local governments to set up retirement savings plans for individuals who do not have access to retirement savings plans at work. In November 2017, the Department of Labor delayed a critical part of the consumer protection rule thatallows retirement savers to sue investment advisors who breach their fiduciary dutyto provide retirement advice that is in the best interest of their client.
5. Weakened protections for workers trying to form a union. Throughout 2017, President Trump made anti-worker appointments to the National Labor Relations Board, an independent agency established to safeguard employees’ rights to organize. Within three months, these Members overturned major pro-worker decisions. Specifically, they overturned a decision that ensured workers can bring all employers to the bargaining table when multiple employers control their pay or working conditions. They also overturned a decision that prevented employers from tipping the scales against unions by gerrymandering union elections.
6.Recommended deep cuts to job training programsthat help workers find good-paying jobs. InMay 2017, the Trump administration sent a budget request to Congress to makea drastic 40 percent cut to job training programs. These programs help youth, adults, and dislocated workers find good-paying jobs and connect employers to qualified workers.
7. Exposed victims of sexual assault and transgender students to potential discrimination and harassment on campuses. On February 22, 2017, the Department of Education sent a Dear Colleague letter withdrawing the statements of policy and guidance protecting the rights of transgender students. In September 2017, the Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights released new guidance that rescinds the 2011 and 2014 documents that explained the Title IX requirements to protect for victims of sexual harassment.
8. Prevented students saddled with debt from gaining relief. Over 2017, the Department of Education delayed implementation of the Gainful Employment rule, which would have prevented low-quality career programs from continuing to market themselves to unsuspecting students. The Department also delayed implementation of Borrower Defense rules, which would have allowed borrowers to receive financial relief from unjustified student loan debt.
11. Sabotaged affordable health care coverage for millions of Americans.In December 2017, Republicans paid for huge tax cuts for billionaires and corporations by cutting health carefor millions of Americans. According to the Congressional Budget Office, the GOP tax bill will increase premiums by 10 percent and leave 13 million Americans without health insurance over the next 10 years. The administration deliberately tried to sabotage the ACA by cutting outreach and advertising to encourage ACA enrollment and by ending subsidies that help working families with their copays and deductibles. On May 4, 2017, the House passed the American Health Care Act (H.R. 1628), which, if signed into law, would have resulted in 23 million fewer Americans with health care coverage.
12.Pushed to undermine consumer protections for small businesses and their employees. Both Congress and the administration have taken steps to try to unravel the ACA’s consumer protections, such as the requirement that small businesses’ health plans cover essential benefits. These benefits include needed coverage, such as maternity care and substance use disorder treatment. On March 22, 2017, the House passed the Small Business Health Fairness Act of 2017(H.R. 1101), which the National Association of Insurance Commissioners warned could actually increase insurance costs for many small businesses. The administration proposed a related rule on January 5, 2018.
Several weeks have passed since Republicans joyfully passed a tax bill that will saddle our country with $1.5 trillion in debt and make it harder for working families to make ends meet. While they will insist that this bill creates bigger paychecks for everyone, in reality it is a giveaway for large corporations and billionaires.
While many Virginians may initially see small increases in their take-home pay, this bill ensures that middle-class tax cuts will only be temporary — and that middle-class families will permanently pay for the cuts later. The nonpartisan Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy estimates that the bottom 60 percent of Virginians will see their taxes increase by nearly $200 in 2027 while the top 1 percent will see a cut of $7,400.
This is just one example of how hugely skewed this bill is in benefiting millionaires and billionaires over working families, and why the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center estimates that 83 percent of the benefits of the bill go to the top 1 percent of taxpayers (those who are making more than $460,000 per year).
We know from experience that tax cuts have never paid for themselves, so this is just the beginning. Once our national debt begins to rise as a direct result of this massive tax cut, the president and congressional Republicans will come after Medicare, Medicaid and your hard-earned Social Security, in addition to cutting services for children, students, seniors, veterans and other key programs.
They will say that the burgeoning deficit we now face can only be paid for by cutting these vital services, but these cuts would not be necessary if the tax cuts had not passed.
This is the Republican playbook: complain about our growing debt; cut taxes, adding trillions to the deficit under the false pretense that growth alone will fix it; and when the tooth fairy doesn’t pay for the drastic tax cuts, turn around and cut the pillars of the social safety net. It is the epitome of hypocrisy to say that our national debt is our most pressing issue and then pass a bill that adds $1.5 trillion (and maybe hundreds of billions more when the dust settles) to the national debt.
Instead of focusing on simplifying the tax code, or making it more fair for working Americans, or reducing the deficit, this bill does the exact opposite. It creates vast new special-interest loopholes, creates a child tax credit that hands thousands of dollars to a family of four earning $400,000 a year but gives just $75 to a single parent of two earning $14,500 a year, and pretends that unheard-of levels of economic growth will pay for the budget hole they have created.
While cutting taxes by $1.5 trillion will undoubtedly produce some economic growth, every credible economist agrees that this is the worst way to do it. Republicans’ favored think tank, the Tax Foundation, estimates that their tax cuts will produce 339,000 jobs. This pitiful number means that we will be spending $4.1 million per job.
To get the best “bang for our buck,” we must consider where else $1.5 trillion could have been spent. Other studies have estimated that an infrastructure bill would create 15,000 jobs for every $1 billion invested. At that rate, instead of 339,000 jobs, investing $1.5 trillion in our nation’s infrastructure would create more than 20 million jobs.
We’ve unfortunately been down this road before. In 2001, Congress was debating what would happen if the debt held by the public was paid off, as projected at the time to occur in 2008. Instead of keeping on the path to paying off the debt and shoring up Social Security and Medicare, Congress passed massive tax cuts in 2001 and 2003, fought two wars and passed the Medicare Part D prescription drug benefit without any plan for how to pay for these costly endeavors.
Basic arithmetic reveals the truth — we could not afford massive tax cuts 17 years ago, and we certainly cannot afford them now. We are forcing the next generation to pay for lessons we should have learned years ago.
Ultimately, the middle class will be forced to pay for this bill, either directly or indirectly. Only the top 1 percent will be spared. Tuition will continue to skyrocket, health care premiums will rise, and our roads, bridges and schools will continue to decay.
It should not go unnoticed that Republican leaders in Congress have already set their sights on “entitlement reform” — better known as cuts to Social Security and Medicare. So it is simple arithmetic — tax cuts for the wealthy will be paid for by cuts in those important programs.
By passing this bill, the president and congressional Republicans have shown that they will always prioritize millionaires, billionaires and large corporations over working families. The American people deserve better from their elected officials.
Rebuild America's Schools Act of 2017– legislation that highlights the need for bold investment in school infrastructure as a means to achieve greater educational equity, while breathing new life into communities and creating jobs.
Opening Doors for Youth Act of 2017– legislation to expand employment opportunities for at-risk and opportunity youth and support community efforts to keep youth connected to school and training.
HBCU Capital Financing Improvement Act – a to bill to modify the HBCU Capital Financing Program and authorize the Department of Education to provide financial counseling that prepares an eligible HBCU to qualify for, apply for, and maintain a capital improvement loan.
Fought Against Harmful Rollbacks
Gainful Employment and Borrower Defense Rules– the Trump administration has delayed implementation of rules allowing career programs that do not lead to good-paying jobs to continue to market themselves to unsuspecting students, and delayed borrowers from receiving financial relief from student loan debt for which the Department of Education has determined they are not liable.
Tip Regulations– the Trump administration proposed a rule that would allow employers to take ownership of workers’ tips as long as the tipped employees are paid at least the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour.
Overtime Rule– the Trump administration initiated a plan to rollback a 2016 rule that strengthened overtime protections for millions of full-time, salaried workers when they worked more than 40 hours per week.
Americans' Retirement Security– Republican legislation nullifiedrules that enabled states and municipalities to expand retirement savings options, and Republicans joined the Trump administration in efforts to delay and weaken the fiduciary rule which requires that financial advisors provide retirement investment advice that’s in the worker’s best interest.
Contraceptive Coverage Rules– the Trump administration released new rules allowing virtually any employer or university to deny contraceptive coverage under the guise of moral or religious objections.
Promoted Democratic Values
Aim Higher – Committee Democrats launched an initiative focused on legislation that would provide all students with access to a meaningful degree that costs less money and leads to a good-paying job.
Better Deal– House and Senate Democrats worked to give Americans the tools they need to thrive and empower families and workers, and to unlock economic growth that will lead to better jobs, better wages, and a better future.
Juvenile Justice Reform Act of 2017– the bill reauthorizes and reforms the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act (JJDPA) to help state and local leaders better serve juvenile offenders and at-risk youth.
The House and Senate rushed through tax bills that will make sweeping changes to tax policy. Most of the benefits go to high-income earners and wealthy corporations, but the attacks on education will hurt us all. The provisions on education threaten students, colleges and universities, research and science, and U.S. innovation and global competitiveness. This will have negative consequences for years?—?or even decades?—?to come.
First, under these bills students will lose the ability to deduct interest on their student loans. That will make higher education less affordable and accessible. Second, many if not most graduate students will be priced out of school if the final bill includes the House bill’s provisions to treat tuition waivers as taxable income. This is going to be crushing for our medical schools and researchers, especially in the STEM/STEAM fields, and result in us falling behind on the discoveries that lead to new products and cures. And finally, taxing endowments, used primarily to help low-income students afford college, will take away opportunities from people who have great potential.
So what happens now and when? Because the House and Senate passed different tax bills, one of two things will happen. There will be a conference committee to reconcile the bills and both chambers will vote again on the new bill, or the House will simply vote on the Senate bill and it will go to the President to be signed into law.
And when? Early this week we return to Washington, DC and a vote could be held as early as this week.
There are many reasons to criticize these bills, but the attacks on education could have very long-lasting effects. I was able to work my way through community college, which opened doors and created opportunities for me to become an advocate for those who couldn’t speak for themselves. I want every American to have the same chance to succeed and to reach for a better future.
I hope a loud and convincing outcry from people across the country over the weekend can stop this recklessness.